Called customer service and laid everything out. The lady said it would be 2-3 days before they could forward a response to my email address. Hopefully it won't ship out before then so if it is wrong I won't be stuck with a jersey I do not want.
Also, IceJerseys has the same two jerseys (image wise) as listed on shop.nhl.com
A 1992 Penguins Lemieux Replica (same as in the images above), and a 1985 Alt Lemieux Replica (solid gold, numbers on the shoulders). Is there any correlation between what shop.nhl.com carries and icejerseys carries? If so, maybe shop.nhl just has the wrong year listed for the black jersey.
Or I might just cancel it all together and order it from somewhere else. *wink wink*